The First Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled that a public school teacher's social media posts are not protected under the Constitution. This decision comes amid controversy surrounding a first grader who was punished for drawing 'any life' below a 'Black Lives Matter' sketch. The child's mother expressed outrage over the school's actions, which have drawn criticism from legal experts and commentators. They argue that the punishment infringes on First Amendment rights, highlighting a broader debate about the balance between free speech and school policies related to social issues. Judge David Carter's ruling has been described as aligning with the school's stance, which some commentators believe prioritizes institutional messaging over individual rights.