OptionProbability
If I accept the Penguin job, at what will I rate my overall life satisfaction in 2 years, on a scale of 0-100?
If I accept the Genesis job, at what will I rate my overall life satisfaction in 2 years, on a scale of 0-100?
If I accept the Genesis job, will I believe it to have been the correct decision in 6 months?
If I accept the Penguin job, will I believe it to have been the correct decision in 6 months?
If I accept the Penguin job, will I believe it to have been the correct decision in 4 years?
If I accept the Genesis job, what will be my bonus in my first full year? (At a rate of 1 percentage point = $3000. So e.g. if it's $100k this answer resolves to 33%.)
If I accept the Genesis job, will my total earnings from it after 5 years be at least 1.5 million?
If I accept the Genesis job, will I believe it to have been the correct decision in 4 years?
If I accept the Penguin job, will my total earnings from it after 5 years (valuing unsold equity at whatever I think it's "really worth") be at least 1.5 million?
If I accept the Genesis job, will I end up leaving on bad terms?
If I accept the Penguin job, will I end up leaving on bad terms?
Will I accept the Genesis job? (As opposed to Penguin, resolves N/A if some weird third thing happens.)
80
79
77
75
64
62
60
59
59
21
21
0
OptionVotes
YES
NO
15088
92
OptionProbability
Proposal: representative security council! Add at least one member with <20k net worth
Proposal: Donate it all to MSF / Doctors without Borders
ACCEPTED: Don't use the bomb before it reaches 10K (minimum)
Donate to Mriya https://manifold.markets/ArtemAvramenko/will-the-mriya-fund-raise-2-million?r=TG9yZWxhaQ
ACCEPTED: Donate 50% to GiveWell, 50% to Internet Archive
Donate 34% to give well, 33 % to internet archive, 33% to mriya
Proposal: add @Stralor to the security council
Proposal: don't use the bomb until it reaches 20k mana kilotons
Proposal: Loan Tumbles 1000 mana to add to the bounty, then add Tumbles to the security council
Proposal: Add @SanghyeonSeo to the security council
Proposal: add @Joshua as a member of the security council
Proposal: Bet it on YES for Michelle Obama winning the 2024 presidential election
Proposal: add @odoacre to the security council
Proposal: Bet YES on the first Yes or No market posted after 1 AM EST on March 9th
Proposal: Vow not to use the bomb on whalebait markets
Proposal: EMERGENCY BACKUP BOMB - donate it all to internet archive in case of pivot backfire
Proposal: Loan it all to @retr0id for 1 month, at 10% monthly interest
Proposal: Donate it all to Givewell (PASSED AWAITING APPROVAL)
Proposal: Bet it all on coinflip markets (51% YES) and see how many times it ~doubles
Proposal: the security council must have at least 3 members to arm the bomb
Drop a 1 kiloton "shot across the bow" spirit bomb directly on the new manifold government https://manifold.markets/bens/will-i-receive-the-mandate-of-the-p
Proposal: Boost Bomb, spend the mana boosting question(s) to be determined
Proposal: Whale Bomb: Use the bomb on a whalebait market
Proposal: a member of the security counsel can be voted off with a supermajority of its members >66%
Proposal: True Love Bomb, spread the mana by making large bets on markets with <3 traders or markets created by new users
Proposal: Create a ticking mechanism with a mana goal and a deadline, such that either: 1) the deadline is reached and the bomb is detonated, or 2) the mana goal is reached and the deadline is extended
Proposal: Give 10% to @geuber_
Proposal: add @AmmonLam to the security council
Proposal: Use it to develop a rival “Coolfold Partner Program,” award it as bounties to promising new/cool market creators
Proposal: Add @Tumbles to the security council
Proposal: Donate it all to Poker Night on Manifund
Proposal: Use the mana to buy tickets for Manifest for spirit bomb contributors who are able to make it
Proposal: Bet it on LK-99 superconductor market (YES or NO to be decided).
add @AbhinavSrinivas to the security council
Proposal: add @KongoLandwalker to the security counsil
Proposal: Cursed Boost Bomb, use it to boost the most cursed/annoying market to impact the feed of every user for days to come
Proposal: Subsidy Bomb, put the mana into one specific market, target to be determined
ACCEPTED: don't use the bomb before it reaches 5K (minimum)
ACCEPTED: require a contribution of at least 1000M for any future member to be considered for the security council
DUPLICATE - NA
ACCEPTED: security council candidates must have 20 YES positions for them to be considered
ACCEPTED: Proposed security council members cannot be considered without reaching 100% YES at some point after having 20 unique YES positions.
ACCEPTED: Proposals need at least 10 more Yes positions than NO positions to be considered (YES positions minus NO positions must be 10 or more)
ACCEPTED: All proposals must have at least 80% to be considered
ACCEPTED: proposals can be cancelled if there are 10 more NO positions than YES positions (they can be resubmitted though)
ACCEPTED: Proposed security council members cannot be considered without reaching 95% YES at some point after having 20 unique YES positions. (amending previous 100%)
ACCEPTED: change approval for resolutions to 95%, and a difference of 20 Y to N for sec council member proposals
Proposal: Poker bomb - use it to fund a massive prize pool for a coolfold poker event
Proposal: Max out a specific Manifund project (TBD)
Proposal: add @stefanie as a member of the security council
Proposal: Distribute among active players in Bronze
Proposal: Poll bomb - give chris enough mana to finish hogwarts/trump polls :)
Proposal: Stochastic Bomb: use it to make as many markets about Jose Luis Ricon and StochasticParrot as possible
Proposal: use the bomb to disrupt manifold politics conditional markets.
Proposal: Use the bomb to create a multiple choice market with 100 answers, and pour the rest into boosting it
Proposal: repeal the ban on using the bomb before it reaches 5K mana
Proposal: add a random number generator to the security council
Proposal: Disarm the bomb until April 2nd 2024
Proposal: Immolation Bomb to protest the pivot
Proposal: Disarmament & Peace, permanently deactivate the bomb
Proposal: Love Bomb, spread the mana from the bomb as subsidy among the top 100 markets on browse
Proposal: block another user's limit order on a specific market, target TBD (ie: set up a new large Limit Order that is slightly below/above theirs)
Proposal: Vow not to use the bomb on any small creators or their markets, without their permission (<1000 traders)
Proposal: Found a Republican PAC to make election predictions on Manifold more accurate
Proposal: Distribute it to all the users that contributed to it evenly
Proposal: the greed ending, split the bomb evenly among members of the security council
Proposal: add @firstuserhere to the security council
97
95
95
95
94
91
89
87
84
81
79
79
77
73
71
71
70
69
69
69
69
67
66
65
65
61
60
56
55
55
55
54
53
53
52
51
51
50
50
50
50
50
50
50
50
50
50
50
49
48
48
48
47
47
44
42
42
41
34
32
32
26
25
23
18
15
11
OptionProbability
Prediction markets are good
Sexism and racism, among other forms of prejudice, are responsible for worse health outcomes, and it’s not overly dramatic for people to treat those issues as public health/safety concerns.
Tenet (Christopher Nolan film) is underrated
[*] ...and things will improve in the future
Scientific racism is bad, actually. (also it's not scientific)
We should be doing much more to pursue human genetic engineering to prevent diseases and aging.
The Fermi paradox isn't a paradox, and the solution is obviously just that intelligent life is rare.
The way quantum mechanics is explained to the lay public is very misleading.
Authoritarian populism is bad actually
Prolonged school closures because of COVID were socially devastating.
Nuclear power is by far the best solution to climate change. [N]
Most organized religion are false
The Many Worlds Interpretation of quantum mechanics
Humans have a responsibility to figure out what if anything we can do about wildlife suffering.
Pineapple pizza tastes good
First-past-the-post electoral systems are not merely flawed but outright less democratic than proportional or preferential alternatives
Liberal-democracy is good actually
Physician-assisted suicide should be legal in most countries
Peeing in the shower is good and everyone should do it
It would actually be a good thing if automation eliminated all jobs.
We need a bigger welfare state than we have now.
Many amphetamines and psychedelics have tremendous therapeutic value when guided by an established practitioner.
The proliferation of microplastics will be viewed as more harmful to the environment than burning fossil fuels, in the long term
Free will doesn't require the ability to do otherwise.
Metaculus will take over Manifold in more serious topics, and Manifold will be known as the "unserious" prediction market site
American agents are in the highest positions in government for more than half the world.
We should give every American food stamps, in a fixed dollar amount, with no means testing or work requirements or disqualification for criminal convictions.
Dialetheism (the claim that some propositions are both true and false) is itself both true and false.
Dreams analysis is a legitimate means of gaining personal insight.
Given what we know about the social and health effects of being fired, even if abolishing at will employment has efficiency costs it is likely worth it.
Mobile UX will be a key explaining factor in explaining the stories of Manifold and Metaculus.
The overall state of the world is pretty good... [*]
If a developed nation moves from democratic to authoritarian government today, it should be expected to end up poorer, weaker, sicker, and stupider.
Factory farming is horrific but it is not wrong to eat meat.
California is wildly overrated.
Political libertarianism
The United States doesn't need a strong third party.
Racial Colorblindness is the only way to defeat racism
People will look back on using animal products as a moral disgrace on the level of chattel slavery.
There's a reasonable chance of a militant green/communist movement that gains popular support in the coming decade.
[N], and to the extent climate activists are promoting other kinds of solutions, they are actively making the situation worse by diverting attention and resources from nuclear power.
Being a billionaire is morally wrong.
Eating meat is morally wrong in most cases.
You should bet NO on this option
The Windows kernel is better than Linux; it’s just all the bloat piled on top that makes it worse
White people are the least racist of any racial group
Technology is not making our lives easier or more fulfilling.
COVID lockdowns didn’t save many lives; in fact they may have caused net increases in global deaths and life years lost.
Light mode is unironically better than Dark mode for most websites
Some people have genuine psychic capabilities
God is evil
A sandwich is a type of hot dog
Climate change is significantly more concerning than AI development.
Astrology is a legitimate means of gaining personal insight.
It's acceptable for our systems of punishment to be retributive in part
Mereological nihilism (composite objects don't exist)
China not having real democracy does more good than harm
AI will not be as capable as humans this century, and will certainly not give us genuine existential concerns
Governments should not support parents for having children that they cannot take care of
Reincarnation is a real phenomenon
Dentistry is mostly wasted effort.
Moral Hazard isn’t real, and all the purported instances of it can be chalked up to coincidence or confounding variables
Donald Trump would have been a better president than Joe Biden
Mass surveillance (security cameras everywhere) has more positives than negatives
Future generations will say that on balance the world reacted appropriately after learning that fossil fuels cause climate change. That the balance between addressing the problem and slowing economies was just about right.
The next American moon landing will be faked
SBF didn't intentionally commit fraud
Humans don't have free will.
AI art is better than human art
Souls/spirits are real and can appear to the living sometimes
Communism just wasn't implemented well, next time it will work
The first American moon landing was faked
The human race should voluntarily choose to go extinct via nonviolent means (antinatalism).
LK-99 room temp, ambient pressure superconductivity pre-print will replicate before 2025
Astrology is actually true.
91
90
86
84
80
78
78
77
77
76
74
74
73
72
72
71
71
70
70
69
66
65
65
60
60
60
59
58
54
53
50
50
50
49
49
47
46
45
44
44
44
44
44
42
41
38
36
35
33
33
33
32
31
30
27
26
26
23
23
22
22
22
21
19
14
13
13
11
9
8
8
7
7
5
5
OptionProbability
I get demoted from master once
I win master once
I create a bot account to compete in silicon league
My mana net worth exceeds 500k at any point in the year
My mana net worth exceeds 1 million at any point in the year
I profit more than 50k mana from a single market
I lose more than 10k mana from a single market
I lose my daily betting streak
My mana net worth exceeds 2 million at any point in the year
I become inactive (no trades for a month)
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
29
21
13
OptionProbability
Ineffective: Any benefits are too small to be worth the drawbacks
Unproven but promising: Too early to tell
Valuable but imperfect: Some healthy adults should consider it, but there are major drawbacks
Harmful/scandalous: Clear serious drawbacks that last beyond cessation of treatment
Wonder-drug: Most adults should consider it
34
26
20
11
9
OptionProbability
Project Hail Mary
The Metropolitan Man
Worth the Candle
The Black Company
Consider Phlebas
Grog (by RW Krpoun)
The Torture Camp on Paradise Street
House of Leaves
HPMOR
The Orphanage
The Shadow in the East
Red Famine
Switch: How to Change Things When Change Is Hard
Rationality: From AI to Zombies
80
77
70
69
61
59
59
57
56
52
51
50
39
39
OptionProbability
More than one AGI individual exists at the time the public finds out that AGI exists.
AGI attempts to make humans more like AGI.
AGI generally has a sense of morality that humans can comprehend.
If more than one AGI individual exists, they are generally friendly to each other.
AGI is generally friendly to humans.
AGI generally views humans as equal in moral worth to AGI.
AGI is generally under the control of humans.
Humans are generally under the control of AGI.
AGI generally avoids interfering with humanity.
Humans are generally friendly to AGI.
AGI has a significant beneficial effect on Earth's climate.
AGI has a significant detrimental effect on Earth's climate.
80
66
66
60
54
54
52
50
50
40
39
33
