Philippe Baptiste, the French Minister of Higher Education and Research, stated that the term "islamo-gauchisme" does not exist, particularly within universities. He argued that the term is not recognized academically and dismissed allegations of infiltration by the Muslim Brotherhood in higher education institutions. His remarks have sparked controversy and debate across political and academic circles. Critics, including academics like Pierre-Henri Tavoillot and public figures such as Fabrice Balanche and Muriel Ouaknine-Melki, have challenged Baptiste's position, asserting that islamo-gauchisme is a real phenomenon affecting university environments. Some commentators accuse the government of denying a societal threat, while others emphasize the longstanding left-wing orientation of universities. Within the government, there have been differing views, with some officials reaffirming a firm stance against islamo-gauchisme. The debate continues to evoke strong responses from journalists, politicians, and intellectuals, reflecting broader tensions about ideology and security in French higher education.