The four-year legal battle between San Francisco Supervisor Dean Preston and conservative journalist Susan Dyer Reynolds has concluded. The dispute centered around Reynolds' lawsuit accusing Preston of violating her free speech rights by blocking her on Twitter, now known as X. The lawsuit was dismissed, marking a victory for Preston, who stated, 'This is a complete victory and Reynolds' frivolous lawsuit against me is now history.' Reynolds had claimed that Preston attempted to remove her newspaper, The Marina Times, from a taxpayer-funded city advertising program after she wrote a critical article about him. Reynolds also alleged that Preston falsely accused her of threatening his family. Despite the dismissal, Reynolds maintains that her First Amendment rights were violated, with Orrick ruling that Reynolds plausibly pleads that Preston violated her clearly established First Amendment rights.