According to the EmpiricalSCOTUS blog, nine of the 50 challenges heard this term by the justices originated from the 5th Circuit and the high court reversed the 5th Circuit about 66% of the time. https://t.co/4A0MmTn2Q8
“That was an interesting point for folks who are with this narrative that the Supreme Court is so conservative,” said Adam Feldman, Supreme Court scholar and creator of the EmpiricalSCOTUS blog. https://t.co/4A0MmTnAFG
“The pattern we have seen this year of the Supreme Court reversing the 5th Circuit on cases that the federal government asked them to take … supports the notion the 5th Circuit, as a whole, is to the right of the Supreme Court." https://t.co/4A0MmTnAFG
The U.S. Supreme Court has overturned approximately two-thirds of the decisions it reviewed from the conservative 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals this term. This trend highlights the Supreme Court's nuanced stance, which may be slightly more centrist compared to the 5th Circuit. Far-right lawyers and lower court judges have interpreted recent Supreme Court signals as a green light to advance their agendas. Justice Kagan has also voiced significant criticisms of the conservative supermajority in her recent public remarks. According to the EmpiricalSCOTUS blog, nine of the 50 challenges heard this term by the justices originated from the 5th Circuit, and the high court reversed the 5th Circuit about 66% of the time. Adam Feldman, Supreme Court scholar and creator of the EmpiricalSCOTUS blog, noted this pattern.